Wow, so American Horror Story is 9 seasons at the moment, which is a pretty impressive run for a Netflix series. I had seen up through “Hotel” previously, but recently binge-watched the whole series up through 1984 (the most recent release as of now). I think that the series is difficult to judge overall, at least not without getting into each of the seasons first.
So a bit about the series and the format first. Each season is themed, or located around a particular location or story. Many of these themes are related to some staple of the horror genre. Most of the actors in each season play roles in other seasons, which means that each season you get to pick out the new roles that each actor plays. Personally, I really like this, it allows for actors to show a pretty broad range over the course of the series, instead of playing the same character for a long time, as you might usually see with a series that has been running about a decade. In a way, the new themes and settings keep the series fresh, and most of the stories don’t overstay their welcomes.
The first season of American Horror Story is “Haunted House”. It’s a really solid start to the series. This season introduces us to the world, and tells us a bit about how ghosts work in this series, and the importance of property lines and remains. Most of the characters feel pretty compelling, and you become invested in nearly all of the characters’ story lines. By the end of the season, it really gets your mind working about some of the possibilities, because while a lot of the stories feel wrapped up, there are a number of loose ends. If you watch the season, and don’t continue on from there, it feels like a nice, contained story.
The story takes place mostly in the then-recent 2011 Los Angeles, with some flash backs to the character’s backstories, that show the history of the horrors that have occurred within the house, and how those horrors continue to haunt the halls. More than simply bad things happening, or ghosts, there’s motivations behind a lot of the madness that is at least mostly clear and understandable. I think that what impressed me though was how many more complex issues the series touches on, giving a more thorough commentary than “school shooter bad”, starting the series’ long struggle with nature versus nurture.
As an anthology series though, the jump in themes from season one to two can be a bit jarring, as the theme goes from Haunted House, to Asylum. This second season takes place mostly in 1964 Massachusetts. The disconnect between the settings allows for your brain to disconnect your brain from the characters that the actors originally play, giving them new personas, and completely disconnecting them from the first season. It also really feels different, as there’s no ghosts in this season. There’s aliens, and Nazis, and inhumane treatment of asylum patients, serial killers, both real and framed, but no ghosts.
This season has a modern-day component to it, but it is scarce in comparison to the first season, but towards the end of the season, most of the pieces connect, with the past connecting to the modern day for a dramatic climax, and while not a happy ending for sure, is mostly satisfying, though the abductions of characters, and the aliens, while shown to definitely have been real, don’t get any follow-up. This was another season that really drew me in, and that I really enjoyed, though I did feel that wrapping up the story, and the epilogue bits were a bit stretched out.
After season two though, we get into season three “Coven”. This season takes place in its concurrent 2013 for the most part, with flashbacks to the 1830’s. It is in this season that we get the introduction of magic, and a glimpse into the afterlife of non-ghosts. It is in this season where pieces from the previous seasons intersect, creating what started by feeling like little callbacks, but later become important threads that arise later.
After this, the seasons continue to change settings, from a freak-show circus, to a very, very haunted hotel in California, to then Roanoke, to Cult, to Apocalypse, and then jump back in time to 1984, with a tenth season on the way. At the beginning of each season I enjoy seeing often many of the same actors play new roles, seeing their ranges, and feel a little delight when a character played by one actress encounters another character, played by the same actress, and the actress must play off of herself. I also enjoy seeing the types of horror tropes that the show both uses and subverts. The series has no problems killing off characters, so there’s an excitement knowing that all of the characters are actually at risk, and it is likely that most or all of them will die. Of course, the show also tells a great story each season, usually with some mysterious elements that will keep you engaged for each season.
Each season is so different than the others that it makes it difficult to judge the work as a whole. A few of the seasons feel a little bit padded out, but overall, the story moves at a decent pace for seasons that are well over five hours long a piece. Additionally, each season has its own statements, on morality, on good and evil, nature and nurture, and while I don’t always agree with some of the sentiments that the show settles on, but it is also pretty clear that their world isn’t exactly our world, and in fact, some of the things that people decide make sense in a world where there are witches, warlocks, ghosts, and demons.
Overall, I enjoyed the show a lot, and look forward to additional seasons, and to find out what ideas they continue to come up with, I am especially curious, as they have apparently cast Macaulay Culkin for a role in season 10. To give a score, I give the series an overall 8/10, while there are aspects that can be improved, you can tell that the people working on it care, and that a lot of hearts were put into it.